Point Based On Books Troubling a Star (Austin Family Chronicles #5)
Title | : | Troubling a Star (Austin Family Chronicles #5) |
Author | : | Madeleine L'Engle |
Book Format | : | Mass Market Paperback |
Book Edition | : | Deluxe Edition |
Pages | : | Pages: 296 pages |
Published | : | August 1st 1995 by Laurel Leaf (first published 1994) |
Categories | : | Young Adult. Fiction. Fantasy |
Madeleine L'Engle
Mass Market Paperback | Pages: 296 pages Rating: 3.85 | 6769 Users | 290 Reviews
Commentary As Books Troubling a Star (Austin Family Chronicles #5)
I know many might find this a terrible thing to admit, but I've always loved A Ring of Endless Light and Troubling a Star best of all Madeleine L'Engle's books--yes, even more than A Wrinkle in Time and its sequels and companions. I'm not sure whether I can even explain why, other than to say that I somehow just really identify with Vicky Austin, more than I ever could with Meg or Cal or Charles Wallace or the twins. This book is sort of part mystery, part travel adventure, part political intrigue, and part coming-of-age story. Vicky gets in over her head when her friend (and crush) Adam Eddington heads to Antarctica with a research team and she's given the opportunity to join a cruise and follow along behind him, to meet up with him when she arrives. Only not everyone on the ship with her is there for sightseeing, and somebody thinks she knows more than she does. The story starts off right in thick of things and then goes back to tell us how Vicky got into such a dire situation. Yeah, sometimes Vicky seems a little old-fashioned, but...I don't know, she still somehow feels real, and Troubling a Star is a total comfort book for me that I just read over and over and over again. Plus, you know, I kind of have that whole obsession with Antarctica thing going. Anyway, this is one of my all-time faves.Particularize Books In Favor Of Troubling a Star (Austin Family Chronicles #5)
Original Title: | Troubling a Star |
ISBN: | 0440219507 (ISBN13: 9780440219507) |
Edition Language: | English |
Series: | Austin Family Chronicles #5 |
Characters: | Vicky Austin, Adam Eddington |
Setting: | Antarctica |
Rating Based On Books Troubling a Star (Austin Family Chronicles #5)
Ratings: 3.85 From 6769 Users | 290 ReviewsPiece Based On Books Troubling a Star (Austin Family Chronicles #5)
this book was extremely stupid, highly highly unrealistic (to the point where it's more unrealistic than anything else that L'Engle has written, and yes, I'm including the Wrinkle in Time series in that assessment), and just flat out BAD. it alarms me how L'Engle went from writing the phenomenal and earth-shattering (for me, at least) Ring of Endless Light and then followed it up with this garbage book where Vicky seems like so much more of a child than she was previously. Was this because sheTroubling a Star: Or, Iceberg Woes For the last book in the Austin Series, young Vicky Austin finds herself trapped on an iceberg in Antarctica! Oh, that crazy Vicky and the situations she gets herself into. How did she end up on this iceberg you ask? Well, you'll just have to read this book to find out!Vicky gets to travel down to South America ALONE to meet her "friend" Adam Eddington (THE THIRD) in Antarctica. He's there doing some research or something. What follows is a tale of adventure,
Ugh, I feel horrible rating this at 2 stars because I usually LOVE L'Engle's books but this one, this one I was not into. I was dying of boredom and I had to literally force myself not to skip to the end (which I kind of ended up doing anyways). I loved seeing Vicky and Adam again (Adam my boy!) and meeting Aunt Serena and Cook was a delight but I spent most of this book just missing Vicky's loud family and the bond they all shared. With Vicky away traveling for 70% of this book her family was
I'll be honest, this is not Madeleine LEngles best work. However, even a second-rate LEngle story is a treat. This one is rather an odd birdpart a story of an angsty teenager trying to find her place in life; part political thriller; part Antarctic travelogue with a strong theme of environmental preservation. (Also literal odd birds: lots and lots of penguins.) Despite some plot weaknesses, I turned the final page with a sigh of content.'Troubling a Star' got off to a slow start, but a few
I'm longing for the first two books in the series where normal things happened to normal people. Now the normal people are getting involved in international plots, nuclear weapons, kidnapping, etc. - oh, yeah - in Antarctica. It's a bit much to swallow. I could sort of go along with that kind of thing in the Poly O'Keefe books, but not here. Again, I think this book suffers from the removal of the character from her normal environment. The other problem is even when there are characters who are
This book was my first Austin Family book, and I really loved it when I first read it. I think it was the first thing I read that resembled a suspense or spy novel. This time around, I still enjoyed it, but more for the connections to Aunt Serena and the past, along with its letters and literature references, than I for the spy implications. Still, this book introduced me to the Austins, and I'm glad I read and re-read it.
I always seem to revisit this series every few years, I love Madeleine L'Engle's voice and the life she gives to Vicky. As an adult it is a very quick read I can read it in probably a day's commute to and from work on the bus. I so enjoy Vicky and Adam and Cook and all the whole Austin family really, re-reading is a little like visiting friends! The fact that it has stayed with me for almost 20 years should be recommendation enough for you to read it!
0 comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.